Magyarok Világszövetsége

 

 

WORLD FEDERATION OF HUNGARIANS

 

WELTBUND DER UNGARN

 

H – 1052 Budapest, Semmelweis u. 1-3.

TEL.: [00-36-1 / 06-1] 267-45-10

FAX / TEL.: [00-36-1/06-1] 485-40-60

e-mail: elnok@mvsz.hu

Adószám: 19672081-2-42

 

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Ej.2007.0033.b

 

On the 60th Anniversary of the Treaty of Paris

 

 

„The Whole Section was Hissing Like a Snake. . .”

 

Why was the Treaty of Paris a Second Trianon?

 

 

            Dezső Sulyok, was the Public Prosecutor in the trial of Hungarian Prime Minister, Béla Imrédy, who was sentenced to death.  Sulyok was the nominee for Prime Minister, whose party, the Smallholders’ Party, won an absolute victory, and who delivered a speech in the National Assembly on February 8, 1946.  This politician, who could not be accused of leaning toward the Right, demanded that the Hungarian delegation, traveling to the peace negotiations, ask for a correction of the ethnographic data and the return to Hungary of a large number of Hungarians, who were living outside the borders, together with the territories in which they lived under foreign rule.  At this point in his speech, the Communists demonstrated strong, violent opposition.  Sulyok writes the following: „The whole section, in which the Communists were sitting, hissed at me like a snake.   They called me chauvinist, war instigator and revisionist . . .” [i]

         After this, the „Hungarian” Government, which had a Smallholder majority, but was Communist-ruled, sent a delegation to the peace negotiations in Paris, whose members – with very few exceptions – did not understand any of the matters, or else did not wish to protect the interests of Hungary [ii]

            On the orders of one of the Communist Foreign Ministry officials, important documents, which would have shed new light on the role of Hungary in the War, were taken from one of the rooms of the Foreign Ministry, where they had been kept, to one of the toilets.  There they were torn apart and, over several months, they were destroyed, without any of their contents being used to reveal the Hungarian truth.[iii]

            The peace negotiations continued.  A number of Hungarian Marxists lived well in Paris for several months with the government’s money and they did as much as they could to harm our people. [iv]

 

           

 

            On February 10, 1947, the Allied and Associated Powers imposed a Peace Treaty on Hungary, which, compared to Trianon, took additional pure Hungarian territories from the state, and obliged the nation to pay the Soviet Union 200 million USD and Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia, 100 million USD each, in war reparations.  The country’s army was limited to 66,000 head, including the border-guards and the river forces. [v]  The armies of the Western allies were obliged to leave Hungary, yet the Soviet troops were allowed to remain there as long as the Soviet troops, stationed in Austria, needed them for supplies and provisions.  The Soviet troops left Austria in 1955, whereas they did not leave Hungary until 1991 because, in the fall of 1956, without a declaration of war, they considered the country to be a theater of war. 

 

            But let us read between the lines of the text of the Peace Treaty:

 

  1.  Compared to the other nations, who took part in World War II., Hungary suffered the largest losses: 15% of her total population.   480,000 died in action, 300,000 in Soviet captivity and, from Hungary and Northern Transylvania, altogether 300,000 died in holocaust concentration camps.  In Sub-Carpathia, 100,000 Hungarians were killed.  In Yugoslavia (formerly Southern Hungary, Délvidék), 40,000 civilians were massacred, 200,000 Hungarians „disappeared” from Slovakia (formerly Northern Hungary, Felvidék) and another 270,000 from Transylvania.  Altogether more than 2 million souls! [vi]

 

  1. Slovakia, among the first on Hitler’s side to attack the Soviet Union with weapons, and in the forefront in accepting the anti-Jewish laws – in whose parliament, János Esterházy, martyred 50 years ago, was the only representative to oppose these laws – was allowed to sit among the victors at the negotiations.(!?)  Capitalizing on this unhoped-for opportunity, particularly in the light of the anti-Hungarian stance of the Peace Conference, she placed claims on more Hungarian territory.  After receiving the pure Hungarian territory of Csallóköz in Versailles as a granary, she now asked for five other Hungarian settlements below Pozsony, as a bridgehead on the left bank of the Danube: Rajka, Bezenye, Dunacsúny, Horvátjárfalu and Oroszvár.  The peace-makers actually awarded her the last three. [vii]

 

  1. The Hungarian Nation received her harshest blow in the face, when the Czechoslovak delegation made an official request that the Peace Conference rule that the Holy Crown be taken out of Hungary and placed under the protection of the United Nations, in a distant state because, while the Crown was in Hungary, the strength of the nation was invincible. [viii] This request was not incorporated into the final text of the Peace Treaty because, at that time, the Holy Crown was already far from the country, in the custody of the American Army and it remained there for more than forty years.

 

  1. Whereas, in January and February of 1946, during the inhumane and illegal population exchange, in teeth-chattering cold, several tens of thousands of Hungarians were expelled from Slovakia (formerly Felvidék, Northern Hungary) across the frozen Danube. Hungary used the value of the properties that the Hungarians left behind to pay Czechoslovakia for the war reparations imposed on Hungary and, in the Treaty of Paris, accepted the responsibility of reimbursing the displaced Hungarians.  On February 10, 2007, 60 years had passed and neither the Communists, nor the „changed regime” of Hungary – neglecting their constitutional responsibility – had reimbursed these hundred thousand Hungarians expelled from Slovakia, whose possessions were used to repay the war reparations, a cost which should have been imposed on the ten million population of Hungary.

How far the „changed” Hungary stands from a constitutional state can be well observed in the two ignored decisions of the Constitutional Court.  The robed body first declared, in its 37/1996 decision, that the neglect to pay restitution was a violation of the Constitution, and it gave the National Assembly a deadline of June 30, 1997 to make up for this negligence.  Seven years later, in its 45/2003 decision, the Constitutional Court declared that the violation of the Constitution had continued and gave a new deadline of June 30, 2004.  Without any result to this day!  The majority of the people entitled to reimbursement are probably no longer living.[ix]

 

  1. The Treaty of Paris – unlike the Treaty of Trianon – did not rule on the question of citizenship of the annexed Hungarians.  Therefore, all those Hungarians who, between 1938 and 1947, regained their Hungarian citizenship, were allowed to retain it after the Treaty of Paris.  Neither the January, 1945 ceasefire agreement in Moscow, nor the Treaty of Paris, and not even the 1948 Hungarian citizenship law stripped them of their citizenship.   However, the Kadár regime made bi-lateral inter-state agreements with Czechoslovakia in 1961, later with the Soviet Union and finally, in 1979 with Ceausescu’s Romania, in which, according to the formulae of Trianon, they automatically took away the citizenship of anyone who did not resettle in Hungary within one year.  There was, however one exception.  Such an inter-state agreement did not exist with the former Yugoslavia.  Therefore, Hungarians living in Northern Serbia (formerly Southern Hungary), in Bácska, Dél-Baranya and Muravidék, are still Hungarian citizens.  Their latent Hungarian citizenship is a fact which the „Hungarian” state, 60 years later, still callously denies. [x]

 

  1. In the peace negotiations in Paris, there was no mention of the genocide committed against Hungarians in the fall of 1944, a crime against humanity which can never be erased.  There was no mention of the Hungarian Auschwitz in Szolyva, where ground glass was mixed into the food of the prisoners of the camp.  In this way, 18,000 Hungarian military prisoners of war and civilians were killed with abominable mercilessness and buried in one communal grave.[xi]  There was no mention of the 40,000 tortured and butchered innocent Hungarian prisoners-of-war, soldiers, Catholic priests and defenseless citizens in Northern Serbia (formerly Southern Hungary).[xii] There was also no mention of the executed civilians of Szárazajta, Gyanta, Magyarremete and  Kishalmágy in Transylvania, nor of the victims of the Földvár death camp.  They also ignored the travelers from Dobsina in Slovakia (formerly Northern Hungary), who were forced to disembark from the railway wagons at the railway station  at Prerov, where 200 women and children were shot and piled up in a heap and, when the bullets ran out, children were even strangled or beaten to death with shovels. [xiii]  There was no mention either, of the ninety adolescents from Csík, who had not even seen action in the war, on their way home at the end of the war, who were shot in the back of the neck in Ligetfalu near Pozsony. [xiv]

The Soviet troops laid siege to Budapest, the capital of rump Hungary, a siege that lasted four months and, 62 years ago, on February 10, 1945, in the course of two days, when the Hungarians broke out of Buda Castle, 60,000 defenders of the castle lost their lives. [xv]  The occupying Soviet troops destroyed the symbol of the Hungarian State, the Heirloom State Flag that flew in Freedom Square, and they ravaged the state, raping close to a million Hungarian girls and women.[xvi]

On the evening that the Treaty of Paris was signed, the Primate of Hungary, József Mindszenty, called the people of Budapest to prayer.  He, himself, led the Holy Hour in the Saint Stephen Basilica.  Ten thousand people repeated after him the following lament, crying and sobbing:

 

            „Omnipotent Creator of all things, O Great God!  Although we had hoped that we would find worldly truth, human understanding and human feelings, our hopes were crazy and stupid.  That of which, through anguished days and agonizing nights, we were afraid has taken place: from the decisions of the nations passing judgment on our country – even in this merciless moment – a further mutilation of our state has taken place.  Right now, in Paris,  they are signing the Hungarian Peace Treaty, the work of world-peace, the  largest division of crests, lands, souls, houses, cemeteries, schools, churches -- the thousand year inheritance of Our Lady and Saint Stephen.  Those who signed it enjoyed the historical moment; the signatories will go down in history and the pens will end up in museums, but we know that these pens with their diamond nibs are more injurious than iron pens, which write on millions of hearts.  Blood spurts out from hearts, tears spurt out from eyes, and trickle and overflow in their tracks. Sighs rise up, lives move convulsively.” [xvii]

 

            Meanwhile, „like snakes the Communist section hissed”, when they were asked not to leave out the mention of the mutilation of the state.  Or, did they know that Bishop Áron Márton and his colleagues, who chose prison and martyrdom, had sent their memoirs to the peace negotiations in Paris, asking for a solution that the majority of the annexed Hungarians be allowed to live in Hungary? [xviii]

 

In Paris, the peace was negotiated and the treaty was signed but, sixty years later, it still has a strong influence on the lives of the Hungarians, like the long drawn out effects of poison.  The majority of Hungarians living today know that Trianon was an anti-Hungarian dictate.  For many, the Treaty of Paris appeared to be a peace treaty.  Sixty years later we have to say:

 

The Treaty of Paris was also a Dictate: the Second Trianon

 

 

            Yet the Trianon „peace” was robbery and, because of its terrible injustice, the great powers never ratified it, neither the Soviet Union, nor the United States.  In the Treaty of Paris, the great powers rubber stamped the mutilation of Hungary in the tracks of Trianon.

 

 

 

 

Budapest, February 17,         2007.                                       The World Federation of Hungarians

                                                           

 

This is a certified true copy: Patrubány Miklós – President

 

 

 

 



[i] Sulyok Dezső - Két éjszaka nappal nélkül, 126. o. - kézirat

 

[ii] Sulyok Dezső, i.m., 358. o.

 

[iii] Sulyok Dezső, i.m., 356. o.

 

[iv] Sulyok Dezső, i.m., 364. o.

 

[v] Encyclopaedia Hungarica, Harmadik kötet, Párizsi Béke - Hungarian Ethnic Lexicon Foundation, Calgary 1994

 

[vi] Erdős László ezredes, a II. világháborús magyar hadisírok felelőse - közlése

 

[vii] Dr. Popély Gyula - közlése

 

[viii] Dr. Zétényi Zsolt - Magyarország Szent Koronája

 

[ix] A Magyar Köztársaság Alkotmánybíróságának határozatai, www.mkab.hu

 

[x] Dr. Gaudi-Nagy Tamás,  …, in Restituto in integrum - Magyar állampolgárságot

 

[xi] Matuska Márton - Vérbosszú a Bácskában,                                                                                                                                                                       

 

[xii] MVSZ Sajtószolgálat - Magyar Auschwitz,  2006. november 1?

 

[xiii] Benes Decrees Taking Victims in 2002, World Federation of Hunagrians,

 

[xiv] Janics Kálmán - A hontalanság évei,

 

[xv] 

 

[xvi] Sulyok Dezső, i.m.

 

[xvii] Mindszenty József - Emlékirataim

 

[xviii] Márton Áron - ….